I feel like this will be a time where some of you that read my posts may disagree with some of my hot takes on this topic. But I don’t post these things for everyone to agree with them so that’s fine.
I remember vividly the first fight I broke up. It was hardly considered a fight and actually took place in my classroom my first year teaching. I was in 4 inch wedges and miraculously did not snap my ankle off while scurrying over and pushing the two 12-year-old boys apart. My adrenaline was off the charts which is hilarious because little did I know that was a cake walk compared to some of the fights I’d separate later in my career.
For some reason I was always in the right place at the wrong time when it came to fights. Being in positions to separate boys twice my size with no one in sight to help me. If I knew I was unsafe, I’d wait or yell to someone that I knew would help me, but when I tell you I had the worst luck with being alone separating fights I’m not joking. I’ve separated a girl fight with upwards of 100 students surrounding us, one of the students tried to push me into the fight. That was cute, I even had to prove it to her mom later.
We once had a fight that was a borderline riot where 13 girls were cited. There’s a part of the chaos where you see me on the CCTV camera just standing there staring at the havoc like I knew deep down this was not what I got paid for. But I managed to hold one of the girls back and only broke a few nails while doing so. That actually happened twice that year, where I was holding a female student back that was so angry and fired up that in the process of getting her to a safe space I’d had nails ripped off my hand.
I once followed a large crowd of students into a classroom where a boy that probably weighed 250 tried to attack another boy around the same size. Desks were flying everywhere and thank god a male teacher came in to assist me because there was absolutely no way I was getting in between those two if they really started going at it.
Let me get to the point. In no way were those all of my experiences, I could tell you about the hilarious 6th grade girl fight I separated too but I want to talk about why I’m bringing all of this up. I want to talk about why students in low socioeconomic areas are more prone to violence and I want to talk about the fact that school districts need to do more about it.
Why do a lot of these students work through their problems with their fists? It’s not “just this generation” either. This kind of behavior is all some of these students know. They grow up in chaotic households and have faced trauma that some of us can’t even imagine. They may not have doting parents who teach them how to work through their emotions properly. They may have no parental figure at all. If you’ve never heard of the ACE test I highly suggest taking it. It asks 10 questions about traumatic experiences you may have faced before the age of 18. You then score 1-10 depending on how many yeses and no’s you answer. Any score over 4 has proven to have lasting effects on people’s brains.
Many students that grow up in low socioeconomic areas score relatively high on this test. This isn’t necessarily an excuse to “throw hands” with anyone that looks at them wrong; but it does provide an explanation as to why they may choose to do so. Providing students with different outlets and more opportunities can help prevent violent tendencies. But districts want to pay their school boards and their superintendents obscene amounts of money instead of putting that money toward programs proven to help.
The last school I was at had fights almost every day. But no matter how much my administration begged; the district never gave us a school police officer. Something about under-funded and blah blah. Listen, the people’s tax dollars go to education, and that means all aspects, instead of providing Title 1 schools with more money than they’ll ever need for school supplies why not take some of that funding and put it toward a salary for a school police officer? As someone that absolutely does not get paid enough to be an educator, a parent, a coach, AND a referee I can tell you how much pressure it would take off those of us that strive toward doing what’s best for these kids.
Did you know if a teacher gets hurt during a fight there’s nothing they can do about it? We can’t even file workers comp. Because it’s ultimately in our rule book that we aren’t supposed to step in between a fight and try and stop it. You’re telling me I should just stand there and watch two kids hurt each other? Absolutely not. I don’t want an armed guard at the school to instill fear into the students, I want someone who is trained (correctly) in defusing situations that will help everyone in the building feel safe.
Anyways, I’m not sure why I woke up today and decided this was the rant I wanted to get on but there you have it. I’ll have the TKAMB lesson plan out next week!